The SEC moves to retire 'compensation actually paid'
The SEC's proposed rewrite of executive-pay disclosure would drop a Dodd-Frank-era measure that, by our analysis of 1,346 companies' filings, sat a median 37 per cent away from the pay figure companies already report.
David (dbking), CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia CommonsThe Securities and Exchange Commission has proposed scrapping "compensation actually paid", a pay measure that differed from reported chief executive pay by a median 37 per cent across 1,346 companies last year, by our analysis.
The proposal, announced on Friday 13 November, would rewrite Item 402 of Regulation S-K, the rule that sets what goes in the pay section of proxy statements. The SEC said the rule was last comprehensively reformed in 2006. Chairman Paul Atkins said in a statement that "the rule has become bloated—reaching nearly the end of the alphabet in its internal organizational system" and that the changes "aim to reduce compliance burdens for companies while remaining faithful to the congressional mandate". Comments are open for 60 days after the proposal appears in the Federal Register; it had not appeared there as of Tuesday, by our check.
What is "compensation actually paid"?
It is the pay-versus-performance figure the SEC created in 2022 to meet a Dodd-Frank Act requirement. It adjusts the summary-table total by replacing the grant-date value of equity awards with their fair value at year-end and changes in that value, so it moves with the share price and can turn negative. Under the proposal, the fact sheet says, the measure would be replaced "with the total amount shown in the Earned Compensation Table", performance disclosure would be limited to cumulative shareholder return, and three years would be shown instead of five.
Companies tag both numbers in their filings, so the gap can be measured. Komposite pulled the SEC's XBRL frames for the 2025 calendar-year period, matched each company's chief executive summary-table total with its compensation actually paid, and kept the 1,346 companies with both. The median company reported $4.40m in its summary table and $3.25m actually paid. Only about a quarter had the two within 10 per cent of each other. The 1,346 are the companies whose filings tag a single chief executive figure for the period, so the count covers most, not all, of the companies that file pay-versus-performance tables; 1,071 of them have fiscal years ending in December.
| How far 'actually paid' sat from the summary-table total, fiscal 2025 | Companies | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Within 10 per cent either way | 322 | 23.9% |
| More than 50 per cent apart | 560 | 41.6% |
| More than 100 per cent apart | 319 | 23.7% |
| 'Actually paid' was negative | 114 | 8.5% |
| 'Actually paid' higher than the summary table | 627 | 46.6% |
| 'Actually paid' lower | 613 | 45.5% |
| Identical | 106 | 7.9% |
The spread cuts both ways. Almost as many companies showed more pay actually paid as showed less, and 114 reported a negative figure, which happens when the value of earlier awards falls by more than the year's pay. Two numbers that move this differently, printed side by side, are what the proposal would collapse into one. The proposed Earned Compensation Table would count stock as earned when it vests and options when they are exercised, a third approach.
What else would change?
The list of disclosed executives would shrink. Named executive officers would be limited to the principal executive and principal financial officer, which the fact sheet says would cut the number "from typically five or more individuals to two officers in most circumstances". The threshold for itemising perquisites would rise fifteen-fold, and the guidance would lose its examples, "including security provided at an executive's personal residence or during personal travel".
| Item | Today | As proposed |
|---|---|---|
| Named executive officers | Typically five or more | Principal executive and principal financial officer |
| Main pay tables | Summary Compensation Table and others | Granted, Earned and Status of Equity Awards tables |
| Pay versus performance | 'Compensation actually paid', five years | Earned Compensation Table total, three years, shareholder return only |
| Perquisite threshold | $10,000 | $150,000 per executive |
| Pay ratio median employee | All employees worldwide, refreshed every three years | US full-time employees, every five years |
The narrative section would get shorter too. The Compensation Discussion and Analysis would have to cover three topics: the objectives of the pay programme in relation to strategy, the material elements of pay and how they are set, and, where applicable, whether the latest say-on-pay vote was considered. The current rule's list of 15 example topics would go. Tables of what executives would receive in hypothetical terminations or changes of control would be replaced by a qualitative description of the material terms, and director pay disclosure would become, in the fact sheet's words, "more principles-based".
The proposal would also drop disclosure of risk-related pay policies and of equity grants made close to the release of material non-public information, and would let companies using long-form registration statements give pay data up to 120 days after year-end. The SEC has published the full proposing release.
The proposal is the latest of several this year that pare back disclosure rules. Komposite reported in September on the SEC's plans to rescind the shareholder-proposal rule and to scrap the pay-to-play rule for investment advisers. The comment period, once the Federal Register prints the release, will run for 60 days from that date.